I am from Kerala and hence this post is mainly based on what goes around in Kerala. I am not too sure what is the situation like in other parts of
There are numerous rules in India/Kerala, some may not make any sense at all and some might be very meaningful. Regardless of the sensibility of a rule, the rule has been formed so that people abide by it. The punishment that can be given out for breaking a rule is given along with the rule. I do not know what the problem of the police is, but they just do not care if rules are followed or not. I am not talking about major crimes like murder or rape. The lesser crimes, breaking of traffic rule and various other rules. Even though these rule are not that serious, they are broken the most and maintaining them is essential for the smooth functioning of society. After all because of lack of implementation of these rules all of us have suffered a number of times. All of us have been stuck in traffic because of a car parked in a no parking zone, or how many accidents have occurred due to over speeding or breaking traffic rules and dont get me started on the transport buses and they way they stop at different bus stops. Its not like people bribe the police so that they do not get caught. A bribe will cost more than the actual fine that they have to pay.
There is this helmet rule in Kerala, even though its absurd, because the law thinks the life of the person sitting in the front is more important that that of the person sitting on the back, but having said that, a law is a law. Same is the case with the seat belt law. The police come out once in a blue moon and checks and selectively catches people. There are so many traffic violations happening in Kerala. People park in front of no parking signs, break the traffic signals, overtake from the wrong side, over speed etc etc etc. Why is the police so reluctant to charge these rule breakers?
Most states in
If you have a law makes sure you implement it. There are laws in Kerala which prohibits smoking in public places; another law prohibits spitting in public places. Should these laws be there is a totally different question. When a law is made, the law makers should make sure that the people are informed about these laws and the punishment for breaking these laws through various mediums. Once that is done with they should implement these laws strictly. If they have no plan to do so then why make the law in the first place? Making a law just for the sake of making new ones is very useless and waste of the tax payer's money.

4 comments:
hi,
In Japan if you lose an item, usually a money filled purse or even valuables, 90% you will get it back. They have such a strong system there,which is not done by law. Because by law, you cant say that YOU HAVE TO SURRENDER ANY LOST-FOUND ITEM TO A POLICE STATION. So my thinking in the direction is, not to fine every jack and dick for wrong parking and taxing them and building new police stations. It is something that should be done at root level, right from the LKG,UKG. I got your point, but I feel it is a knee jerk reaction, a feeling that comes from the thinking that the world can be changed with barrage and stick. We need to be more elegant than that, aint it?
@manu..good point....any thing will be good if the foundation is good. Lot of problems will be reduced if proper teaching is given in the school level. Having said that, the situation here is quite pathetic. People have a sense of an untouchable feeling. Every tom dick and harry breaks the laws(traffic and other such) and this results in chaoses. Even if police dont fine every person at lest 60% of the rule breakers should be dealt with(depending on the crime). The people here even if they are have a good grass root training, by seeing other people get away with the law so easily tend yo break the law them self.
So i guess we should find a balance.
I don't think that your point on bribes being more than the fines is really correct....In that case, the traffic police will never get a bribe...I do agree that in Kerala it is on the higher side...In Chennai, I heard you can get away for not having a license for a mere Rs 30...Also, the assumption that no one ever breaks traffic/other laws in the west is not very correct...While it is true that a higher percentage of people abide by the laws, it is not uncommon to see drivers going through the red light in Berlin or Paris, or for that matter, anywhere else in these countries
@jikku....Rs 30 nice :D....well i have broken quite a few traffic laws :D..4 crying out loud i started taking my scooter when i was in 5th..and i have seen many people breaking them...no 1 checks anything here....they dont ask 4 bribes....they just damn lazy....and in the west ...of course people break laws and stuff....but the chances of them getting caught is much higher
Post a Comment